Biodiversity and Human Health

Description

A scientist working for an environmental advocacy group in Indonesia fights against the transfer of a portion of state owned native forest to a palm-oil plantation. The case raises ethical issues including how to establish the value of natural lands, environmental justice, and communicating science.

Abstract

This biodiversity case is part of a larger collection of Life and Environmental Science ethics education resource sets on ethics of emerging biotechnologies, big data in the life sciences, human enhancement, and biodiversity. Doctoral students from Arizona State University’s Center for Biology and Society developed the resources under the direction of Karin Ellison and Joseph Herkert between 2014 and 2019.

Body

The archipelago country of Indonesia contains one of the world’s twenty-five “biodiversity hotspots” (Myers et al. 2000). Such “hotspots” are locations on the planet that are home to exceptional concentrations of variety of life, particularly in terms of endemic species. Indonesia is also home to a large and growing population of over 250 million people living at a density of 142 people per square kilometer (World Bank 2016). (For comparison, almost 320 million people live in the United States at a density of 35 people per square kilometer.) To meet the economic and social demands of a dense, large, and growing population, some areas of the Indonesian islands have been developed for urban, industrial, and agricultural uses. Unfortunately, such development is sometimes in close proximity to and threatens destruction of the ecosystems that constitute Indonesia’s biodiversity hotspot.

Kiera—a recent PhD graduate of a large university in the United States—has returned to the Indonesian island, Sumatra, where she was born and raised to work for a local chapter of an NGO, Friends of the Earth International.  In Sumatra, Friends of the Earth and Kiera are fighting against the transfer of a portion of state owned native forest to a palm-oil plantation. Past efforts to halt plantation expansion relied on emphasizing the spiritual and intrinsic (existence) value of the biodiversity in the forest. Plantation owners, employees, and some local villagers argued that the plantation harbors economic benefits that outweigh the non-monetary value of the intact ecosystem.

Although agriculture will bring short-term economic benefits to the community, the long-term costs of lost biodiversity may be severe. Recently, Kiera learned that destruction of biodiversity could have human health implications.  In particular, recent studies have shown that decreasing levels of biodiversity may lead to an increase in outbreaks of vector-borne and parasitic diseases, such as malaria, dengue, zika, and schistosomiasis (all occurring in Indonesia) (Bonds et al. 2012; Morand et al. 2014; Keesing and Ostfield 2015). Outbreaks may necessitate a costly healthcare response. In addition, there are studies linking disease outbreaks to poverty (Garchitorena et al. 2015; Bonds et al. 2010; Bloom and Canning 2000).

Furthermore, the endangerment of local lives due to nearby environmental degradation could be considered a violation of environmental justice (the fair treatment of all people with respect to environmental laws, policies, and regulations).

Due to the potential public health costs and environmental justice violation there will be a public vote regarding expansion of the plantation (a democratic decision process in an only recently democratic nation). In advance of the vote, Kiera’s organization has charged her with putting together a public education forum. However, some of the evidence for disease outbreaks in response to declining biodiversity is conflicting. Kiera has decided to focus on the academic literature and media that claim biodiversity destruction is likely to lead to disease outbreaks. This way, she believes she is more likely to persuade locals who will feel they are endangered by palm plantation expansion. Perhaps she will initiate a local environmental justice movement.

Discussion Questions:

  1. Should Kiera use the evidence of biodiversity’s relationship to human health to argue that biodiversity should be protected? Why or why not?
  2. How should Kiera deal with the presence of conflicting conclusions in the literature? Should Kiera present both sides of the scientific debate? Why or why not? How can she communicate scientific uncertainty to plantation developers and local citizens?
  3. What are the strengths and weaknesses of an economic value vs. intrinsic value argument for biodiversity protection? Which argument do you think will have more sway with plantation developers and government regulators? Why?
  4. Given possible human health implications of biodiversity loss, do you think that protecting and maintaining biodiversity is necessary to achieve environmental justice? Why or why not?
  5. How could increasing public participation in environmental decisions lead to more environmentally just outcomes? What do you think would be the outcome of a public debate in this case?

 

Bibliography:

Allan, B. F., R. B. Langerhans, W. A. Ryberg, W.J. Landesman, N. W. Griffin, R. S. Katz, ... and L. Clark. 2009. Ecological Correlates of Risk and Incidence of West Nile Virus in the United States. Oecologia 155: 699-708.

Barclay, E. 2010. “Declining Biodiversity Speeds Spreading of Disease.” NPR Environment, December 2. http://www.npr.org/2010/12/02/131758921/declining-biodiversity-speeds-spreading-of-disease

Barclay, E. 2012. “As Biodiversity Declines, Tropical Diseases Thrive.” NPR Public Health, December 29. http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2012/12/29/168210441/as-biodiversity-declines-tropical-diseases-thrive

Bloom, D. E., and D. Canning. 2000. “The Health and Wealth of Nations.” Science 287: 1207-1209.

Bonds, M. H., D. C. Keenan, P. Rohani, and J. D. Sachs. 2010. Poverty Trap Formed by the Ecology of Infectious Diseases. Proceedings of the Royal Society Biological Sciences 277: 1185-1192.

Bonds, M. H., A. P. Dobson, and D. C. Keenan. 2012. “Disease Ecology, Biodiversity, and the Latitudinal Gradients in Income.” PLoS Biology 10: e1001456.

Civitello, D. J., J. Cohen, H. Fatima, N. T. Halstead, J. Liriano, T. A. McMahon, C. N. Ortega, E. L. Sauer, T. Sehgal, S. Young, and J. R. Rohr. 2015. “Biodiversity Inhibits Parasites: Broad Evidence for the Dilution Effect.” PNAS 112: 8667-8671.

Douglas, M., and A. Wildavsky. 1982. Risk and Culture. Berkeley: University of California Press.

Ezenwa, V. O., M. S. Godsey, R. J. King, and S. C. Guptill. 2006. “Avian Diversity and West Nile Virus: Testing Associations Between Biodiversity and Infectious Disease Risk.” Proceedings of the Royal Society London B 273: 109-117.

Garchitorena, A., C. N. Ngonghala, J. Guegan, G. Texier, M. Bellanger, M. Bonds, and B. Roche. 2015. “Economic Inequality Caused by Feedbacks Between Poverty and the Dynamics of a Rare Tropical Disease: The Case of Buruli Ulcer in Sub-Saharan Africa.” Proceedings of the Royal Society Biological Sciences 282: 20151426; DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2015.1426.

International Monetary Fund (IMF). 2009. World Economic Outlook, October 2009: Sustaining the Recovery. Washington D.C.: International Monetary Fund.

Keesing, F. and R. S. Ostfeld. 2015. “Is Biodiversity Good for Your Health?” Nature 349: 235-236.

Keesing, F., L. K. Belden, P. Daszak, A. Dobson, C. D. Harvell, R. D. Holt, ... and S. S. Myers. 2010. “Impacts of Biodiversity on the Emergence and Transmission of Infectious Diseases.” Nature 468: 647-652.

Keesing, F., R. D. Holt, and R. S. Ostfeld. 2006. “Effects of Species Diversity on Disease Risk. Ecology Letters 9: 485-498.

Lopez A. D., C. D. Mather, M. Ezzati, D. T. Jamison, and C. J. L. Murray. 2006. Global Burden of Disease and Risk Factors. Washington D.C.: World Bank.

Mace, G. M., H. Masundire, and J. E. M. Baillie. 2005. In Ecosystems and Human Well-Being: Current State and Trends: Findings of the Condition and Trends Working Group, Vol. 1, Ch. 4. Millennium Ecosystem Assessment Series. Washington D.C.: Island Press.

McCauley, D. J. 2006. “Selling Out On Nature.” Nature 443: 27-28.

Millennium Ecosystem Assessment. 2005. Ecosystems and Human Well-Being: Synthesis. Washington, D.C.: Island Press.

Morand, S., S. Jittapalapong, Y. Suputtamongkol, M. T. Abdullah, and T. B. Huan. 2014. “Infectious Disease and Their Outbreaks in Asia-Pacific: Bio-diversity and Its Regulation Loss Matter.” PLoS ONE 9: e90032.

Myers, N., R. A. Mittermeier, C. G. Mittermeier, G. A. B. da Fonseca, and J. Kent. 2000. “Biodiversity Hotspots for Conservation Priorities.” Nature 403: 853-858.

Pielke, Jr., R. A. 2007. The Honest Broker: Making Sense of Science in Policy and Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Reyers, B., S. Polasky, H. Tallis, H. A. Mooney, and A. Larigauderie. 2012. “Finding Common Ground for Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services.” Bioscience 62: 503-507.

Runte, A. 2010. National Parks: The American Experience. Lanham, MD: Taylor Trade Publishing.

Salkeld, D. J., K. A. Padgett, and J. H. Jones. 2013. “A Meta-Analysis Suggesting that the Relationship Between Biodiversity and Risk of Zoonotic Pathogen Transmission is Idiosyncratic. Ecology Letters 16: 679–686.

Sandifer, P. A., A. E. Sutton-Grier, and B. P. Ward. 2015. “Exploring Connections Among Nature, Biodiversity, Ecosystem Services, and Human Health and Well-Being: Opportunities to Enhance Health and Biodiversity Conservation. Ecosystem Services 12: 1-15

Swaddle, J. and P. Calos. 2008. Increased Avian Diversity is Associated with Lower Incidence of Human West Nile Infection: Observation of the Dilution Effect. PLoS ONE 3: e2488.

UNCTAD. 2008. The Least Developed Countries Report 2002. New York and Geneva: UNCTAD.

United Nations. 2016. “Sustainable Development Goals.” Accessed July 15. https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/?menu=1300

US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). 2016. “Environmental Justice.” Accessed July 11. https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice

Wood, C. L., et al., 2014. “Does Biodiversity Protect Humans Against Infectious Disease?” Ecology 95: 817-832.

World Bank. 2016. “Population Density.” Accessed July 8. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EN.POP.DNST

World Health Organization. 2016. “Climate Change and Human Health: Biodiversity.” Accessed July 11. http://www.who.int/globalchange/ecosystems/biodiversity/en/

 

Links:

World Health Organization:
http://www.who.int/en/

Convention on Biological Diversity:
https://www.cbd.int/health/

Notes

The author wishes to acknowledge the contributions of Karin Ellison, OEC - Life and Environmental Sciences Editor, and Joseph Herkert, OEC Engineering Co-Editor. They provided valuable input in selecting topics and crafting the resources.

Commentary